The greatest stock-picker alive has a message for ordinary investors — and it’s not “pick stocks.”
In Part 1 of this series, we went deep inside Buffett’s checklist: the moat, the management filter, the margin of safety, the owner earnings calculation. It’s a rigorous, demanding framework. It takes years to build the skill to apply it well.
So here is the question you may be sitting with after reading that: What if I don’t have those years? What if I’m just an ordinary person trying not to make terrible decisions with my savings?
Buffett has an answer for that, too. And it’s been sitting in plain sight since 2013.
What He Actually Said
In his 2013 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders — a letter he writes himself, every year, in plain English — Buffett described what would happen to his wife’s money after he dies.
His Berkshire shares will be donated to philanthropic organizations. What’s left as cash will go into a trust, managed by a trustee, for his wife’s benefit. And here is what he told that trustee to do with it:
“Put 10% of the cash in short-term government bonds and 90% in a very low-cost S&P 500 index fund. (I suggest Vanguard’s.)”
That’s the whole instruction. Ten percent in short-term government bonds. Ninety percent in a Vanguard S&P 500 index fund.
Then he added this:
“The goal of the non-professional should not be to pick winners — neither he nor his ‘helpers’ can do that — but should rather be to own a cross-section of businesses that in aggregate are bound to do well. A low-cost S&P 500 index fund will achieve this goal.”
And then, the sentence that most people gloss over:
He said he believed this strategy would produce long-term results “superior to those attained by most investors — whether pension funds, institutions or individuals — who employ high-fee managers.”
Read that again. Warren Buffett, the most successful active stock investor in history, told his own wife’s trustee to put 90% of her money in a Vanguard index fund. And he predicted it would beat most professional money managers.
Why He Said It — The Bet That Proved the Point
Buffett didn’t just say this. He put money on it.
In 2007, he made a public wager with a hedge fund firm called Protégé Partners. Buffett bet $1 million that a simple, low-cost S&P 500 index fund would outperform a basket of professionally managed hedge funds over the next ten years. Protégé accepted.
The bet ran from January 1, 2008 — right as the financial crisis hit — through December 31, 2017.
The S&P 500 index fund returned 7.1% compounded annually over that decade. The five hedge funds in Protégé’s basket returned an average of 2.2% compounded annually.
Total gain over the decade: the index fund gained 125.8%. The hedge funds gained between 2.8% and 87.7% — with one of them returning less than 3% over ten years.
The difference wasn’t hidden volatility or unusual luck. The difference, in large part, was fees. Hedge funds typically charge a management fee of 1.5–2% of assets every year, plus 20% of any profits. On an investment returning 7% before fees, a 2% annual drag can cut your ending wealth by a third or more over a decade.
Buffett donated his winnings to Girls Inc. of Omaha.
The Reasoning: Why the Non-Professional Can’t Win the Same Way
Buffett’s criteria in Part 1 — the moat, the operating history, the owner earnings model — are not a formula anyone can follow without deep knowledge and years of practice. Knowing the checklist is not the same as being able to apply it.
Buffett himself spent decades studying businesses. He read annual reports as a teenager. He apprenticed under Benjamin Graham. He compounded his analytical ability the way a business compounds earnings — slowly, deliberately, over time.
When he says the non-professional should own a cross-section of businesses rather than try to pick winners, he isn’t being modest. He’s being precise.
The market is full of professionals who are trying to pick winners. Many of them are smart, disciplined, and deeply experienced. Their research is sophisticated. And on average, after fees, they still don’t beat a simple index.
If professionals with every advantage — research budgets, Bloomberg terminals, access to management — can’t reliably outperform a passive index fund, it would be surprising if an ordinary investor, working with less information, less time, and higher costs, could do better.
Buffett’s 90/10 instruction is not plan B. It’s what he genuinely believes is the right answer for most people.
Why Short-Term Treasuries — Not a Broad Bond Fund
The 10% in bonds deserves its own explanation, because it’s often misunderstood.
Buffett didn’t say to put 10% in a bond fund. He said short-term government bonds — meaning U.S. Treasury bills and short-term Treasury notes. There’s a specific reason for that.
Short-term Treasuries are the closest thing the investment world has to pure cash. They don’t fluctuate much in price. They mature quickly. You can get to your money when you need it.
The job of that 10% isn’t to generate returns. It’s to provide liquidity — that is, access to ready cash — so that if the market falls sharply and you need to withdraw money, you take it from the bonds rather than selling stocks at the worst possible time.
This is important. When markets crash, the worst thing a long-term investor can do is sell stocks. Every investor who sold during the 2008 financial crisis, or in the March 2020 pandemic drop, and waited too long to get back in, lost years of compounding. The 10% bond cushion exists to prevent that. You have cash you can draw on while stocks recover. The 90% stays invested.
A broad bond fund — one that owns long-duration government or corporate bonds — doesn’t serve this purpose as cleanly. Long-duration bonds can fall in price when interest rates rise, which often happens when economic conditions are uncertain. They can be volatile at precisely the wrong moment. Short-term Treasuries don’t have this problem. Their value barely moves.
The instruction isn’t about earning yield on the 10%. It’s about never being forced to sell the 90% at the wrong time.
What Actually Matters — The Criteria, Not the Name
Buffett named Vanguard in that 2013 letter because Vanguard was, at the time, the most visible provider of genuinely low-cost index funds.
But the point isn’t Vanguard specifically. The point is the criteria the fund has to meet:
-
It tracks the S&P 500. Not a sector. Not an industry basket. The full S&P 500 — five hundred large American companies across every major part of the economy.
-
The expense ratio is extremely low. The fee you pay to own the fund should be a fraction of a percent per year — 0.03% to 0.10% is where the best S&P 500 funds sit today.
-
It is broadly diversified. Five hundred companies is not concentration. No single holding can make or break you.
-
You hold it for a long time. The mathematics of compounding require patience. Buffett said in 2017: “Consistently buy an S&P 500 low-cost index fund. Keep buying it through thick and thin and especially through thin.”
Today, Vanguard, Fidelity, and Schwab all offer S&P 500 index funds that meet every one of these criteria. Fidelity’s S&P 500 fund has an expense ratio of 0.015%. Schwab’s is 0.02%. Vanguard’s is 0.03%. The differences between them are negligible over a lifetime.
Any of them would satisfy Buffett’s instruction. The fund is the vehicle. The strategy is the destination.
The Apparent Contradiction — Resolved
In Part 1, we built out Buffett’s stock-selection checklist in detail. In this post, he tells his wife to buy an index fund.
That feels contradictory. It isn’t.
Buffett’s stock-picking is built on skills that took a lifetime to develop, in partnership with Charlie Munger, backed by a permanent capital base, with no forced selling, no redemption pressure, and a sixty-year track record of judgment to draw on. He operates in a context that almost no investor in the world can replicate.
His advice to ordinary investors is not about what he does. It’s about what works for people who aren’t Warren Buffett. And his answer — consistent, low-cost, long-term ownership of the broad market — is not a consolation prize. It is a strategy that, over history, has outperformed the overwhelming majority of professional investors.
That is Buffett’s advice. Not “pick stocks like I do.” Pick an index fund. Hold it. Don’t touch it.
A Note to Luca and Lili
I want to make sure you understand what this post is really saying.
Your grandfather — me — spends significant time analyzing individual stocks. I built an analytical system. I use discounted cash flow models and screen for growth criteria and look at financial statements. This is how I invest.
But if you asked me today what to do with the first money you save as adults — assuming you don’t have the time or the inclination to go deep into financial analysis — I would tell you: put it in a low-cost S&P 500 index fund, set up automatic contributions, reinvest the dividends, and don’t look at it more than once a year.
That is the honest answer. Not because analysis doesn’t work. But because the habits that make analysis work — patience, discipline, emotional control during downturns, willingness to hold for years — are hard to develop. An index fund forces those habits on you. It doesn’t let you panic-sell individual positions. It just tracks the market.
Start there. Build from there. And never stop learning.
— Papa
The One-Sentence Summary
In his 2013 Berkshire Hathaway shareholder letter, Warren Buffett instructed his wife’s trustee to put 90% of her inheritance in a very low-cost S&P 500 index fund and 10% in short-term government bonds — not to generate bond returns, but to maintain liquidity and prevent forced stock sales during downturns — because he believed this simple strategy would outperform most professionally managed alternatives over the long run, and his decade-long bet against hedge funds proved it.
Buffett’s recommendation — own a low-cost S&P 500 index fund — converges with Jack Bogle’s lifetime argument from a different direction. Buffett gets there from the evidence of his own career; Bogle gets there through pure arithmetic. For the complete mathematical case, see The Bogle Method, Part 1: Stop Trying to Beat the Market.
Next: Warren Buffett’s Advice, Part 3 — Buffett is a student of investing history. He has read everything Benjamin Graham ever wrote. He attended Columbia Business School to study under Graham directly. In Part 3, we look at where Buffett came from — the teachers and ideas that shaped his thinking — and why understanding those roots changes how you read his advice.
— Jim